a free little tool for makers

Is my marketplace still worth it?

A fair question this year. The answer is in last month's statement, not in the headlines. Type four numbers and see what your marketplace really takes, and whether your own people alone would pay for a shop of your own. Nothing you type leaves this page.

What your marketplace takes

Type last month's sales and fees.

On buyers who already knew you

These are the orders an own shop could take: repeat buyers, followers, people from your market table.

Your own shop, for those same orders

Add a plan price and card fee to compare.

So, worth it?

Your answer appears here.

Where to find the numbers

  1. Your marketplace's monthly statement has sales and fees as totals. On Etsy it's in Shop Manager under Finances. Use an ordinary month, not December.
  2. "Already knew you" means buyers who would have found you anyway: repeat customers, people who follow you, people who met you at a market. If you're not sure, 20% is a gentle start.
  3. For the own-shop side, use the price page of the platform you'd actually pick. Plans and card fees differ by country.

Good to know

  1. It's rarely all or nothing. Many makers keep the marketplace for new buyers and send their own people to their own shop.
  2. Sales that come in waves are normal for makers. Your own mailing list is the one thing that lets you start a wave yourself, wherever you sell.
  3. Fees are only half of it. A marketplace brings strangers; an own shop needs you to bring them. If most of your buyers find you by searching the marketplace, that's worth paying for.

Thinking of moving? The free moving-shop plan and art and AI checklist help, or see all free maker tools.

Want a little site of your own one day? Studio by Scribble Snacks builds them for makers, and the free Site Check gives three specific ideas for the shop you already have.